Forest Plot
Best Practices
Overview
The forest plot is useful for presenting the results of a meta-analysis — that is, a study of studies. Each row in a forest plot represents one study. A linear graph for each study indicates the result estimate and the lower and upper 95% confidence interval bounds. A vertical line represents the “no effect” point. Additional columns can provide the plotted information in text format as well as additional information, such as number of events, population size, etc.
[image here]
Typically a forest plot uses a linear scale for continuous outcomes or a logarithmic scale for binary outcomes (e.g., risk ratios, odds ratios, etc.). The WCMS allows you to specify the scale type.
[note on Total row if available]
With the Subtext option, you can provide notes on details such as p value, heterogeneity, etc.
Data Requirements
For each study represented in a forest plot, your source data must include a study label/ID, a numeric result estimate (“Relative Risk” in example data below), and the lower and upper bounds for the 95% confidence interval (in separate columns). Each study graph is automatically generated from the result and the CI values. A weight column can be specified for determining the size of each result indicator. The chart designer also supports additional text columns from the source data, such as the number of study participants.
[image here]
- Go to ExamplesSee examples on this page that illustrate key options.
- Building in the WCMSSee key tips and guidelines for working with forest plots in the WCMS.
- TP4 UX Best Practices [PPT - 14 MB]For general guidance on colors, layouts, and overall presentation, see this overview of TP4 best practices.
Guidelines
- Many general audience members may not be familiar with forest plot conventions, so, unless your chart is intended solely for scientific audiences, include a summary of chart results in plain English.
- Interpretation of a forest plot depends on the type of outcome being studied (particularly the desirability of the outcome). The WCMS chart designer allows you to provide X-axis labels on the left and right sides of the “line of no effect” to help readers interpret the results.
Forecast Chart with Single CI Series
This example is a “live” version of the chart pictured at the top of the page but with different colors. Users can hover over the visualization to see data details, including the CI values. (On mobile screens, users can click in the visualization area.) See example data file [XLS – 4 KB].
Forecast Chart with Multiple CI Series
The chart below is the same as the example above except that, in addition to a 90% CI series, it has a 50% CI series. Note that sequential shading is used to differentiate the CI series. The example source data [XLS – 10 KB] has columns that are not included in the chart or supporting data table. Any additional columns such as these can be included in the data table via the Columns panel in the WCMS chart designer.